

I'm sure you've read the Grand List of Console Role Playing Game Cliches. It lists over a hundred commonplace themes of Japanese RPGs, and you'll find that Legend of Heroes III doesn't stray very far from that list. The fact that we're on a third Legend of Heroes game in less than two years should attest to the undeniable truth that it's much too easy to create a fantasy world and have teenagers run around saving the world (with an animal sidekick to boot).
Legend of Heroes III feels completely cookie-cutter, from beginning to end. The characters feel uninspired, with forgettable designs, and even less memorable personalities. Unfortunately, every character and town is named, and many quests involve you having to find a specific person. Will you be able to remember where generic character X is? I hope so, because you won't be able to progress in the game without completing these arduous tasks (and they are quite numerous!).
There simply isn't enough motivation for you as a player to continue on your quest. In fact, you'll constantly have to remind yourself what the quest actually is. You control Forte, the standard run-of-the-mill nice guy that comes from a quaint village. You're accompanied by the bumbling girl Una, who has a crush on you; and your surprisingly vigorous grandfather. Inexplicably, all of you have the innate ability to fight the various monsters that come in your way in your quest to ... uh, find music? You're on the look-out for Resonance Stones, which will unlock the mysterious Water Melody. Yay?

The story and the characters won't do much to keep your interest, and neither will the gameplay. The battle system feels extremely antiquated. It's a turn-based battle system that has little to no quirks that keep your interest. Where's active battle time? Not here. Where's an extensive magic system? Team commands? Anything? You'll find your choices to be surprisingly limited. However, it's not like anything else is really necessary: you can simply press X continuously to simply attack over and over again to get the job done. Because there isn't any strategy in the game, each battle becomes more of a chore than a challenge of wits. Although the battles aren't necessarily engaging, you'll find yourself going through hundreds, simply because you level up at a snail's pace throughout.
Unfortunately, leveling up also feels antiquated and limited. You can't assign attribute points, or customize your character in any significant way. You can, of course, buy predictably stronger armor and weapons throughout the game. There's also some magic, but don't expect the depth of a title like Final Fantasy III on the DS (and that's based on a game that came out more than a decade ago!).
At least the game looks pretty solid, and sounds even better. The environments are bright and colorful, and the character models that appear in conversations look sharp. Unfortunately, the sprites for the in-game characters leave a bit to be desired, as they move stiffly, and seem to feature limited animation. The exploration controls also feel a bit finicky, with your movement never feeling as precise as it should. Word to the wise: play with the analog nub over the D-Pad, as the D-Pad doesn't seem to allow for diagonal navigation. Strange.

Conclusion
Legend of Heroes III may be simplistic, but that may be part of its charm. It's highly accessible for players, especially because the story is completely independent of its predecessors. RPG gamers will enjoy the colorful, bright graphics, and the excellent soundtrack. The lack of load times, and ability to save anywhere in the game is a great feature that all PSP games should feature. While the complete lack of originality has certainly disappointed me, fans of the genre may appreciate the game's adherence to conventions. There are far more frustrating RPG games available on the PSP, and Legend of Heroes III's welcoming atmosphere may hit the spot. Younger gamers may especially appreciate the easy-going nature of the game. However, the rest of us won't lose any sleep over missing this game.
PSP Fanboy Score: 6.0













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
1-30-2007 @ 12:30AM
Tristan said...
The game could have been scored higher, it is the best RPG series to date and concludes with its best attempt to date
Reply
1-30-2007 @ 12:45AM
Namenlos said...
"The fact that we're on a third Legend of Heroes game in less than two years should attest to the undeniable truth that it's much too easy to create a fantasy world and have teenagers run around saving the world (with an animal sidekick to boot)."
Maybe you should actually do some research and look into the original release date of these games before you go making uninformed, snide remarks. Or would that be too much work for you, the typical haughty game reviewer?
Reply
1-30-2007 @ 9:27AM
Jono said...
This is a remake of a game that came out ages ago. Of course it will feel dated, just like FF III DS (which was great for old schoolers like us). Remembering 'generic X' charaters name is part of playing a RPG and continue to exists even in recent AA titles like DQ VIII.
RPG titles should be reviewed by people who understand the genre.
Reply
1-30-2007 @ 1:44PM
Andrew Yoon said...
I'm sorry for not knowing the history of the LoH franchise. However, reviews are usually meant for gamers that are completely new to a game, and I think my opinions remain valid. Being a remake doesn't excuse it from poorly executed design choices. While I thought it simplistic, I do note that RPG gamers may enjoy the formulaic nature of the game. Clearly, you can enjoy mindlessly battling over and over again, but for gamers that need a little bit more, I'll stand by my review.
Thanks for your opinion though! You may have swayed some people into getting the game, if they were on the fence! =)
Reply
1-30-2007 @ 2:13PM
txa1265 said...
I had no idea of the history of the series before the first game came out, and really enjoyed the first one quite a bit as I mention in my review (http://www.gamerdad.com/detail.cfm?itemID=2991)
In the review (http://www.gamerdad.com/detail.cfm?itemID=3326) of the second one I commented:"Last year's Legend of Heroes: A Tear of Vermillion was a bit of a surprise. Although it was derivative and somewhat uninspired, it was charming and entertaining beyond what objective analysis suggested. Namco returns to the Legend of Heroes world with a sequel that is actually a prequel—that's right, everything in this game happens before the original. It features the same whimsical design and richly detailed graphics and soundtrack as the original, but loses much of the charm due to lackluster characters and changes to the battle system removing any strategy or challenge."
I have not gotten terribly far in the third one yet (too busy with Pirates! and Mazes of Fate (GBA)), but there is much of the original charm - and it already feels better than the second game. Yet I am aware that charm can run thin very quickly if there isn't serious gameplay to back it up. We'll have to wait and see.
As I said, I had no idea about the history either, but neither is it pitched as a remake of a classic - if publishers want us to see something that way they need to sell it as such! Even if you crawled from under a rock there would be no mistaking FF III for a new game - it is mentioned *everywhere* that it is a remake of a classic.
Reply
1-31-2007 @ 11:56AM
qrayg said...
Great! Another review by someone who knows absolutely nothing about the LoH series. If the game copied all of the other RPG's you mentioned you would have probably cried "copy cat" and graded it even lower.
The LoH series is a great game set and needs to be reviewed by someone who has played all of the previous games.
Reply
2-03-2007 @ 3:48AM
Strangler said...
why dont they ever bring the good rpgs out of japan for the psp. I mean they have already tales of radiant, and tales of destiny 2, disagea, brave story, princess crown, kingdom of paradise 2, etc. why dont they translate any of them?
Reply
2-03-2007 @ 9:33PM
traumzustand said...
I own the first game and still haven't managed to get through it. It is godawful boring! Normally I really enjoy rpgs, and have played dozens, but this one just doesn't have anything that can keep my interest. I completely agree with the reviewer, as the makers of this game don't really seem to be trying to make a great game, they just seem to be making something 'safe' to get by and make money.
Reply
2-05-2007 @ 9:24PM
Melchiod said...
I need help in the game - any help out there?
Reply